I'd be all in on a Miller reunion.
Honestly, here's what I would do this off season as of now. I know it's not going to be even close, but meh.
Resign Didi to a 2 year 20 million deal, I stole this idea from RAB. lol.
I'd tender everyone else too.
Signings.
Patrick Corbin. 5 years 19 million per.
Daniel Murphy 2 years 21 million
Andrew Miller 2 years 22 million
David Robertson 2 years 26 million
Trades:
Carrassco for Hicks, Green, and Cessa.
Betances for May, Santana, and Sheffield
Jon Gray for Greg Bird and Holder
AJ Cole to the Guardians for cash
Sonny Gray for Zach Brown and Payton Henry
Derek Dietrich for Acevedo
I took a little off of my original Guardians deal. Selling high on Dellin to a desperate Dodgers who I think will also sign Ottavino. I love Bird, but I think Gray can rebound. Bird goes home to Colorado and Gray gets paired with Rothschild. Yankees sell high on Holder too. No way we can dump Ellsbury off on anyone.
C: Sanchez
1B: Voit
2B: Murphy
SS: Torres
3B: Andujar
LF: Stanton
CF: Gardner
RF: Judge
DH: Ellsbury (more of a rotating DH, but for purposes of this list Ells here)
Bench: Romine, Wade, and Torreyes. with Dietrich being a super sub
CC, Severino, Corbin, Tanaka, and CC
Chapman
Robertson
Miller
German (turn him into a 2 inning RP and see if you have a Betances v2)
Tarpley
Kahnle
Gray, let's face it no way those starters stay healthy. I think Jon Gray would be in the rotation come May.
DL: Didi, Monty, Heller
Triple-A rotation
Sheffield
Zach Brown
Adams
Loaisiga
King
That's a 201 million dollar payroll, a great team but a team that can make improvements in season too. Very flexible roster.