" I'm actually fine with doing this. It seems logical for one owner or GM to respond to moves of another team."
I'll just disagree alittle here.... your argument can certainly work as well.
I don't think a G.M. should respond too much to rival moves. I think some people are just feeling so burned by the Teixeira thing.
When Arod came to the Yankees after he was supposed to come to the Red Sox, what could the Red Sox do? It stung for awhile, but the Red Sox survived by having already built a World Series club with Schilling and Foulke being added.
The problem this year? The Red Sox had holes and couldn't turn to plan B - There wasn't one. So, Cashman 1, Theo 0
But Theo has actually built a model of success by not wanting to counter every George-Hankster move, or play "keep-away" like that poster 26 to 6 wants the Yankees to do if Holliday might come to Fenway.
The Yankees don't need to keep Holliday from the Red Sox. They already have a World Series contender and can feel confident about their club without needing to keep Holliday away from Yawkey Way and they don't absolutely need Holliday on the Yankees.
Anyway, we can agree to differ on this...