I agree that we should trade Penny to make room for Buchholz, and it has nothing to do with Penny's performance today. I suggested it yesterday. Nothing against Penny's he's done an alright job. He's been more solid than his numbers suggest. But I think Buchholz has the potential to do much better. And he's at the point that he's not getting anything out of AAA anymore, so to keep him there any longer is stunting his development.
But I don't feel like NOW is the time to make a trade. We have plenty of time to wait and see how Smoltz does before we make a decision. And who knows, maybe Buchholz will break his toe or something in the next week.
Come July 31st, however, I would like to see Buchholz given a spot in the rotation. If he struggles, we still have an absurd amount of depth in Bowden, Masterson and Matsuzaka.