I am all for someone being punished for having broken a rule or law.
I am not sure how I feel on this Rose issue. It is clear that he broke a MLB rule by gambling on games while involved with those games.
But what about MLB and their seeming conflict with one of their own big rules? MLB has gotten into bed with gambling with their alliance with Draft Kings or just fantasy. The only difference seems to be that now baseball has a seemingly palatable way of getting paid for money being bet on their product.
So I am in conflict over this issue.
To me this has much less to do with "has Rose been contrite and has he reformed". Rather, I am looking at the moral and ethical stance of MLB. I say they are hypocrites.