I am with you on this.
I don't like the idea that "there are other ways of strengthening the lineup" or that Papi can be replaced in other ways.
If you lose 3/100 all at once, you should look to replace most or all of it at once. That makes the most sense. Counting on increased WAR from other players is just dumb.
I still like my idea of snagging both EE and Beltran.
Move Hanley to 3rd, put EE at first, and let Beltran DH. Of course one can mix and match during the season.
Grab some schlock BP arms and throw them at the wall.
Done.