I think Hanley needs to be given a little bit of rope this spring. If he hangs himself with it, so be it. There is still a good amount of upside to him, but I hope Farrell is able to give Shaw an honest shot if Hanley really struggles.
Pablo is a fat stinky turd. I hope he plays well and can regain his form. I don't think he will, but I'll try to remain hopeful. If they can squeeze two decent years out of him (2016 and 2017), I won't complain about his contract going forward. Maybe he just needed a year to adjust to AL pitching? His defensive problems are a big red flag though. It's not like he was adjusting to a new position the way Hanley was.