I think having Renfroe hit against RHP is setting him up to fail. He just can't hit RHP.
Cordero looks lost right now, but I'd still take him over Renfroe against RHP. I think there's a chance Cordero gets optioned in May if he doesn't turn it around.
I'm not pleased with what the plan was for the corner OF. My guess it's just a stop gap before they bring up Duran midseason. Also, Cordero and Renfroe are cheap enough that you could waive them if it doesn't get any better. s***, both Franchy and Renfroe still have options.