I can name you 10 managers who are WORSE than Francoma just off the top of my dome.
Joe Girardi- New York Yankees: No explanation needed.
Ozzie Guillen-Chicago White Sox: Hurts his players' confidence, and his big mouth brings bad rap to his team.
Ron Washington-Texas Rangers: Bullpen management is suspect, does not play his lineup according to the other teams' weaknesses even having the offensive strength to do so.
Ken Macha-Brewers: He overmanages, rarely has the players' back, and can run a bullpen to the ground if not given enough depth.
Dusty Baker-Cincinnati Reds: Master of destroying young pitchers' arms, refuses to acknowledge the superiority of some youngsters over some past-their-prime veterans hurting his teams in the process.
Lou Piniella- Chicago Cubs: His stubornnes against change as well as the constant airing of his frustrations leads to an always tense clubhouse and the loss of a lot of W's in the W-L column.
John Russell-Pirates: Not given much to work with, but his lack of leadership is easily identifiable by the lack of inspitrational figures inside the team, and he has a slow hook and sucks at bullpen management.
Don Wakamatsu-Mariners: Still unproven, but has early during his tenure a quick hook on his SPs and bullpen overmanagement issues, that can hurt pitchers' confidence in the long run.
Bud Black- San Diego Padres: Can certainly manage a bullpen with little to no talent, but his lack of dynamism while making his lineup and putting things in motion on the rare occasions that this offense (anyone not named Gonzales or Giles) gets on base hurts his team, this is a stagnant offense, he needs to play small ball, and he doesn't do it nearly with enough frequency.
Dave Trembley- Baltimore Orioles: He has a really slow hook, and that bullpen is decent, he lets his team lose many a game by leaving the starter just an inning more than he should, and that is a fatal flaw for a manager.
So guess what, Francona is not nearly as bad as a lot of people say, actually, he's quite good, he may be a little too faithful in some of his players sometimes, but a lot of the time, that pays off, just ask Dustin Pedroia and Kevin Youkilis, and they'll tell you that Francona's faith in their abilities is one of the main reasons that they are currently MVP candidates.