What does that have to do with Curt Schilling? :dunno:
Dr. Altchek had full access to all medical reports, x-rays, MRIs, and other tests in making his opinion regarding Schilling's case. Altchek did diagnose rotator cuff involvement:
http://sports.espn.go.com/mlb/news/story?id=3383181
But Altchek still recommended that Schilling go the rehab route, not the surgery route, demonstrating that he believed that there was no rotator cuff tear that would not respond to rehab. What Altchek DID believe is that Dr. Morgan's recommended surgery, coupled with the rotator cuff issue, would certainly leave Schilling unable to pitch in 2008. (Boston Herald, Feb 8, no longer available via link, original link http://www.bostonherald.com/sports/baseball/red_sox/view.bg?articleid=1071967
).
But here's the key part, and it's exactly what TheKilo is posting:
Dr. Altchek saw ZERO chance of Schilling's recovering to pitch in 2008 if he had surgery. Schilling had the opportunity to have surgery, regardless, but it would have violated the terms of the contract he'd signed, and it would've probably cost him millions of dollars. Schilling chose rehab and a paycheck. It didn't work; now he's free to have surgery and to compete in the 2009 Free Agent market.
But the position that rehab was doomed to failure from the start is a case of 20-20 hindsight, not the opinion of all competent doctors last winter. Dr. Altchek is VERY highly regarded, and he recommended rehab; furthermore, Schilling was pitching from a mound in early June--rehab almost DID work.