I will give you Beckett in a big game. That's obvious. Over the course of a season, Wang/Beckett are a wash. He's had 38 wins the last two years. Cumulative ERA, etc., over the last two years go to Wang. Everyone points to his abysmal failure in the playoffs, and is correct in doing so. However, over the course of a season, they are pretty much a wash. Matsuzaka and Pettitte are close, and over the course of the season, the combo of Pettitte/Wang and Dice-K/Beckett wont differ by more than 2 win IMO.
The back end of the rotation is another wash. Buchholz, Lester, and Wake compared to Kennedy, Hughes, and Moose can go either way. The loss of Schilling hurt you guys big time. I like to think my pinstripe boys will outshine the Fenway trio, but if I was on your side, I'd think the other way.
As for offense...I know it's early, but let me enlighten you. Manny's cheating a bit. He started to flail at the outside pitch last year, so he's moved in about an inch to make up for it. I was floored when Wang threw it by him, but when I checked the replay I realized he was in about an inch or so from last year. Damon is doing the same thing from our side. Giambi has been doing it for the last few years. Don't be surprised if Manny hits about 40% more near-homers this year that just go foul. The danger you guys face is if Papi starts showing his age as well.
Just remember what happened to you guys in 2005 after you won in 2004. I don't have to remind you of history, do I?
Class dissmissed.