For 2022, the Sox are in a bit of a quandary. This team is a pumpkin right now. Too many holes.
Pen is a mess. Honestly, the only guys who’ve been consistently ok are Whitlock and Sawamura. Ottavino becomes an FA at season’s end and I think Whitlock jumps into your rotation next year. So for pen, you’ve got Taylor, Barnes, Sawamura and DHern. You need to add a closer and a high leverage setup man to that mix to be competitive.
For rotation, Whitlock and Sale are locks, IMO. Houck is probably a lock as well, but as you’re seeing now, he’s not a three time through the lineup guy. If he doesn’t add a pitch, he might flip flop with Whitlock and jump into the pen. But for now you’ve got Sale, Whitlock, and Houck. Pivetta likely earns the 5th spot. Eovaldi likely ends up as your 2. There’s your 5. You could live like that, but having two rookie/first time full time big league starters is asking for injury. Bloom will add a veteran starter. My bet is it’ll be a Morton type near the end of their careers on a short term deal, not a high end talent on a long term deal.
Lineup, I think JD opts out. I honestly do. He should land himself a 3 yr deal and if he does so, you allow it. You sign Schwarber as your DH and roll from there. Verdugo, Kike, Devers, Xander is a good starting point, but Xander is entering his final year. Bloom is a value guy. There’s no way in holy hell he allows Xander to opt out. If they don’t negotiate an extension, I do think he will be moved. There’s no shortage of good SS’s hitting the market and maybe he can snag one of them cheaper than the cost of Xander’s extension. Devers is also getting up there in service time. My bet is Bloom will try to negotiate something with him, but it sounds like Devers is a one year at a time guy. If they don’t negotiate an extension, 2022 will be his final year in Boston.