He's a 2 pitch pitcher with control and durability issues. He's in your rotation for now, but my bet is the sox sell on him before he turns into a relief pumpkin.
I gave Ben a C. For now. I am not sure Cespedes is a 40HR hitter in Fenway. Yes, he has power to spare, but he also K's a massive amount and doesn't walk. While he's probably a 30HR guy, I doubt he gets to 40. Yes he has an 80 arm, but he is a butcher who uses his arm to get a better defensive reputation than he deserves. Did anyone see those two throws he made in successive games? What did they have in common? Both balls were badly butchered before he unleashed a hell of a throw. If you had him for 3 or 4 years, I'd say it's a good deal. But you don't. The thing that actually makes this a palatable deal is the draft pick the sox get, which will increase your pool for the draft next yr. This deal is a C for the most part
The Lackey deal was interesting. You dealt a horse who is under control for 2015 for a starter with durability and control issues and a DH playing the OF who is playing like s*** this yr. This deal is a D with the possibility to be a B if Craig can find himself.
The Miller deal was solid, since you got a guy who is #3 in the Oriole system behind Gausman and Bundy for a lefty reliever. I'd say a B
The Peavy deal was an A. Getting two prospects with A level stuff who are a little down this yr for a guy who should have been DFA'd is an A.
The Drew deal is an F for the sox. Yes, you saved money. I think we are all happy Henry can now buy a bigger yacht. But you just handed the Yankees an audition on a guy they could have been stuck with on a long term deal if things didn't work out. That's huge