Kilo,
Obviously I am a homer, and that is not to be forgotten. But looking at the yankee minor leagues and then seeing what is said about their kids, you have to see how stacked the pitching is. And this isnt just because of the personell, but on the depth of the personell. If a few guys fail, then more than a few are there to step up. That is the hallmark of a good minor league system. In the past, we always had one or two hot rookies coming up, one would fail, one would get traded and we'd be running the same ******** out there day after day. Now, we have a pitching system that is really good, and it is on Cashman for that. Just look at what you have seen thus far.
Guys with MLB debuts this or last yr...
Karstens- fringe rotation guy who when he is right will throw strikes. Likely a long reliever or an NL 4 or 5 starter
Rasner- fringe rotation guy who can throw strikes and has had success to this point. Likely a long reliever or NL 4 or 5 starter.
Wright- if he can throw strikes in the bigs like he has in the minors, he has a future in the back end of the rotation.
Hughes- ace potential.
Clippard- middle of the rotation potential
DeSalvo- likely reliever or NL starter.
So just the past 100 or so games, 6 guys have come up. 1 with ace potential, 1 with middle of the rotation potential, and 4 fringe guys. All 4 have had at least one successful start and have shown flashes of being solid.
But look at what is coming down the pipeline...
AAA-
Steven White- Mid-rotation starter if he can ever stay healthy
Ross Ohlendorf- Mid-rotation starter or setup man if he can stay healthy
Humberto Sanchez- out with TJ surgery, but will be a setup man/closer next season
JB Cox- setup man of the future, out with elbow surgery (not TJ)
Chris Britton- strong season in the majors last yr, dominating in the minors. Relief power arm.
AA-
Jeff Marquez- Middle of the rotation potential, dominating AA
Alan Horne- Ace potential, dominating AA
Kevin Whelan- closer potential, recently converted to pitcher (3 yrs ago), still has control issues, but is dominating AA
A+-
Ian Kennedy- dominating A+ ball ridiculously, mid rotation potential
Joba Chamberlain- ace potential
George Kontos- dominating A+ ball, mid rotation potential
McCutchen- dominating A+ ball, back end potential, possible reliever
Mark Melancon- TJ surgery, closer potential if he gets healthy
Christian Garcia- mid rotation potential, TJ surgery
Claggett- relief potential, throw in in the Sheff trade
A-
Ivan Nova- too early to tell, but has been hyped in the scouting circles.
Robertson- signed way over slot to come out of college, closer potential, DOMINATING ridiculously, needs to move up.
Norton- old for the league, last yrs draft pick, likely a reliever
Then you have McCallister and Betances in EXT St who both have very high potentials, Betances' potential is the highest in the entire minor leagues in some sites opinions. And then there are the DSL guys who all have very high ratings coming out of the DSL as 16 and 17 yr olds on 2 DSL leagues that dominated. The yankee DSL teams the past 2 yrs have been near the top or won the championship.
So it isnt that our minor league pitching is one or two stars and then a bunch of non-prospects. We have 3 or 4 high end prospects and then a bunch of middle tier prospects and they are all approaching the bigs without much hundrance. This is all on Cashman and Oppenheimer. They drafted and traded very well to build up a lot of arms for future deals and future in this organization.
Now dont think I am so naive to think that all of these guys will fill their potential. Chances are 70% of them wont make it or will be nothing more than a cup of tea guys. But the high quantity makes it very likely that we could rebuild a quality rotation from within.