Guys, I dont want to sound like the yankee fan here (or do I), but VMart and Lee would fill every hole imaginable like a Peter North/Jenna Jameson sex toy party.
VMart offers you a part time switch hitting catcher, capable of spelling the suck that has been Jason Varitek and sparing you from the suck that has been George Kottaras. Varitek's hot start has kept his detractors at bay. But the OPS has fallen every month this season from April's .881 to .824, .750, .691. And to make the suck worse, since the ASB, he's 4 for 25 with a .462OPS. Couple that with Kottaras' .631OPS and you have a positional sinkhole. And it isnt like you're losing defense. Varitek is setting a new low for futility in throwing out baserunners, now at a rate of 15%. In his defense, VMart's isnt good either, but his history would suggest that he should come up to his 30% baseline in limited duty. Regardless, you arent losing much by sitting Vtek a bit more.
Then there is the possibility of using VMart at 1b. I know there are complicating factors with LaRoche, Youkilis and Lowell. But lets be realistic. Lowell sucks in the second half with regularity AND is going to have trouble staying healthy. He will need to be cut back to part time duty. Youkilis would then split time between 1B and 3B. LaRoche is a fine fill in at that juncture, but he also cannot hit lefties, something VMart can. Also, VMart can DH against lefties as well to get Ortiz out of there. The funny thing is, Ortiz is hitting just about where he hits vs lefties this yr, in the low .700 range in OPS. The problem is, he's doing the same against righties now. Regardless, it would add some oomph to multiple positions and give the sox an option of having a versatile lineup.
Then with Cliff Lee, well, its a no brainer. Lee was a Cy Young last yr. He sucked in 2007, but his career before that was really, really solid. Something came apart in 2007, so it isnt like he rose from nothing. This yr, he is pitching like a #2 pitcher. And if you looked at the sox rotation with Wakefield on the DL, they could use any pitcher capable of throwing the ball over the plate and not seeing it get hit back at them at incredible velocities. Outside of Beckett and Lester, the 3-5 slot has been inconsistent, terrible, pick your adjective. Regardless, that is where you are losing games. Both with a meager offense and with awful pitching outside of your top 2 starters. This deal would fix almost every problem you have right now.
So then, it becomes, what would you give up. Well, VMart and Lee are 30 and are FAs after 2010. I would assume the sox would be able to work something out with both of them to keep them in Boston through their primes, so it isnt like this would be a 1 yr rental. I would assume the haul would have to be great. Then again, it could also propel the sox past the yankees again into the best team in baseball realm. So you have to take that into account too. It would have to start with your best pitching prospect and your best hitter. Buchholz and Anderson would be the starting point and I would assume they would want Bard as well. I am sure you can bargain one of the three above out for a package of some guys lower. But it would hurt, a lot. Then again, settling your rotation into a 3 headed monster regardless of what Wake and DiceK do, and then getting a switch hitter with power who can catch and play 1b at a younger age is nice too. You gotta give a little to get a little. And if I were the sox, the time is now.