I don't think that is what he's worth, but a pitcher who puts up 150 innings in the bigs is worth something in this day and age. Plus, arbitration will compare him to other players with his kind of production. And right now, those guys are still getting paid at rates prior to 2009 when the economy wasnt as bad. 2008 wasnt that bad of a season either, especially in Oakland where he was a top notch reliever. And, if 2007 gets into the equation, he was very durable as a starter for Oakland. He is what he is, but in arbitration, he would have been able to command much more than he got. Think about it, Melky Cabrera commanded more than Gaudin did and Melky was 1 yr shorter in time and had a miserable 2008.