2009 Edition:
THE LOCKS:
PITCHERS:
1. Josh Beckett
2. Jon Lester
3. Clay Buchholz
4. Daisuke Matsuzaka
5. Ramon Ramirez
6. Billy Wagner
7. Hideki Okajima
8. Daniel Bard
9. Jonathan Papelbon
10. Takashi Saito
POSITION PLAYERS:
11. Kevin Youkilis
12. Dustin Pedroia
13. Alex Gonzalez
14. Mike Lowell
15. Jason Bay
16. Jacoby Ellsbury
17. JD Drew
18. Victor Martinez
BENCH:
19. David Ortiz
20. Jason Varitek
21. Rocco Baldelli
"QUESTIONABLES":
22. Michael Bowden
23. Manny Delcarmen
24. Paul Byrd
25. Tim Wakefield
26. Nick Green
27. Jed Lowrie
28. George Kottaras
29. Joey Gathright
30. Brian Anderson
"LONG SHOTS":
31. Hunter Jones
32. Gil Velazquez
33. Chris Woodward
34. Josh Reddick
35. Marcus McBeth
36. Jeff Bailey
37. Dusty Brown
The way I see it, there are four open spots remaining. I think they are going to want to carry a 3rd catcher because they have done that the last two seasons, so I think Kottaras makes the team.
MDC, in my opinion, has pitched himself off the postseason roster for now. The last guy out of the pen needs to be someone who can pitch multiple innings. I think it comes down to Byrd or Bowden, and I'll take the young kid with some upside and better stuff.
Middle infield backup seems to be decided with Green's injury, I think Lowrie gets the call.
As for 5th OF, I think the Sox would benefit more from Gathright's speed than Anderson's defensive prowess.
In short, I think the final 4 spots go to:
Kottaras
Bowden
Lowrie
Gathright