You know what? You're right, I forgot they were banking on Pedroia to come back and make a run. Still, what was the best BP arm that was moved at the deadline? Qualls? Wood had a pretty bad start to the year with the Guardians, at that point was he really an upgrade to what they already had?
In all honesty, losing the players they did was the principal reason they are not playing in October. Yes the bullpen sucked but when you have Bard/Papelbon closing it out you've got one of the best tandems in the game. If Pedroia, Youkilis, and Ellsbury are healthy for the season, there's no doubt in my mind they contend for a playoff spot (not claiming they make it when it looks like TB and NY win 95), even with their bullpen now.