Even though the issue of whether Sexson is elite or not is totally unrelated to the reason I owned you. That had to do with your admittedly incorrect statement about the relationship between K's and being an elite player. Let's not forget that. Nevertheless, I will respond to you regarding whether Sexson is an elite player.
His career numbers may not indicate that he is an elite hitter, but these career numbers don't miss by much. However, he put up elite-quality numbers last year. He was 8th in the league in OPS, ahead of Konerko, Godzilla, Sheffield, Tejada and Michael Young. He was 6th in the league in Homers and RBI. He trailed only AROd, Manny, Ortiz and Konerko in Homers. That's pretty good company. He trailed ARod, Ortiz, Manny, Texeira and Sheffield in RBI. He was ahead of Vlad, Matsui, Hafner and Tejada. Plus, he had 99 runs scored. I think he is only now reaching his full potential and he is an elite hitter. In light of the company that he shares, it is almost impossible to argue that he is clearly not an elite player.