The FO doesn't bad mouth players to run them out of town. They were going to part ways with those guys any way. Also, no one is arguing that those were not sound business decisions. However, they and every other team uses the press as a tool. Whenever they move a popular player during the season, the negative stories start to appear before the deal. When the moves are made after the season, the stories often wait until the guy is gone. It's a way of getting the fans behind the moves. If there are no physical issues to discuss, there are articles about the guy being a scumbag. Before 2008, we knew that Manny was a flake etc., but do we really believe that he just became a scumbag in 2008. What about all the "Nomar was a Scumbag" stories. Is it a coincidence that these were 2 of the most popular Red Sox players in team history? I don't think so. They used the press to get the fans behind the moves. Is it a conspiracy? That's a silly way of characterizing it. It's called public relations. They are using the Press to sell the FO move. Are the stories planted? They are probably not for the most part. I think the press knows a lot about this stuff, but they refrain from printing it while the player is on the team, because they don't want to get on the wrong side of the press or the FO. After the player is gone, they print the stuff, because they don't need the player anymore, and they know the FO will not be opposed. Some of the stuff is planted. The Manny and the Traveling Secretary story was planted IMO. I also think that a lot of medical info (like Bay's Knees) is planted. This is not about running a player out of town or a conspiracy. It's about Public Relations for the team.