I realize that we were lucky to be facing the A's yesterday, and I don't disagree with most of the rest of your post. However, my point is that we will not be facing a .200 hitting team every day, and this bull pen doesn't have the talent to pull this team through the tough spots. There are no go to guys out there. It's heart attack time. Arms are needed now. We can't wait for Bailey to come back in August. IMO, that will be too late.
You wonder how I can say that the game wasn't bull pen proof? If you need 5 relievers to finish off a game in which you had an 11 run lead in the 7th and a 6 run lead when you turned the game over to the pen, the pen didn't do it's job. Bobby V should have been able to go to 1 maybe 2 pitchers to mop up the rest of the game, but he couldn't. This group actually let the tying run get to the on-deck circle with no one out in the 8th inning. You say that things wouldn't have looked so bad if Punto hadn't dropped the pop up, but on the other hand things may not have turned out so well had it not been for Pedroia's stellar DP on a scorching 1 hop liner by Reddick. That was a very nice play. The pen needs arms.
As for AGon in RF, I agree that is what needs to be done. I am not so sure that it will be done. AGon didn't get any significant OF time in ST. Has anyone heard that he has been shagging flies during the regular season? I hope that he plays RF, because pulling Ortiz out of the lineup will have the same results as last year in the NL parks-- an offensive power outage.