There is a very big line as to how much credit Duquette gets and how much Theo gets.
Dan brought in the likes of Pedro, and yes he deff ripped Seattle for Tek and Lowe. Manny goes in as a wash because of his ridiculously bloated contract and in some people's opinion he shouldv'e let manny go abck to CLE where he was happy. However in the process, he drained our farm, built up our salary, finished behind the Blue Jays in some cases in the AL East, and lets not forget the Rocket episode.
Theo brought in players such as Mueller, Foulke, Schilling, Timlin, Ortiz, etc. and for what? Next to NOTHING. Not only did he sign quality players for some no-names and low salaries, but he also re-filled our minors with talent of which we talk about becoming big stars later, and also has set us up to win perenially for the upcoming years.
Now some might say, but Theo let Pedro, and signed the wrong SS. Yeah but theyre not exactly his fault. Pedro decided that us offering him what he deserves was a slap in the face, and lets face it, we're in a world where money talsk, so he joined his brotehr Omar in New York. As for Renteria, yes it turned out a mistake, but pre-signing him, he was overall a much better, or at least more secure choice than OCab, it wasn't Theo's fault "the dirt was too bumpy".
The line comes down as follows: Yeah, Dan helped, but he hurt us in the long term while doing it. Lucky for us Theo has given us a better outlook on the future, and got us over the hump in 2004.