Schilling hasnt been "great". Wins is not a very good way to judge how well a pitcher has pitched. Jason Marquis has 12 wins, it doesnt mean hes having a great season. Johan Santana is having a great season, Justin Verlander is having a great season, Liriano etc. Schilling is having a good season however he is not as great as he once was. Thats my overall point. Jim Thome however is on his way to 50 HR's. One of his best seasons ever. Thats why I'm voting for him.