I think Manning has more talent. However, Brady also hasn't had Harrison and Wayne to throw to his entire career. I think if you put Brady in the Colts offense the last 4-5 years, Brady puts up similar numbers. We will actually get a taste of what Brady can do this season as he finally has a great wide recieving core to work with. With the weapons that he had yesterday he looked almost unstopable. I know Branch, Givens and Brown made a nice trio, but lets be honest that is no Wayne, Harrison, Stokely. I think that has to be a huge consideration when comparing the two QB's.