I'll agree with MGB in that Amare shreds Duncan head to head. Watch the next Spurs/Suns game that Amare plays in.
In two regular season games against Tim Duncan last season, Amare averaged 36 points, 7 rebounds. In the playoffs, he averaged about 37 points, 10 rebounds; including 42 points and 16 rebounds in the game the Suns were eliminated.
Sure, Duncan's got two rings, then again, I don't think Amare was in High School when Tim Duncan got drafted into the NBA. Team accomplishments should not be used in individual debates or else, to change sports for a brief second, Mark Rypien or Trent Dilfer are better than Dan Marino.
Quick question -- who would you take on your team, considering they're about equally as good? The 29 year old? Or the 23 year old?
That's why we're talking about Amare.