I do too, but to be fair (at least to someone like a700) I don't think so many people are jumping on what he didn't do last year, as much as they see a guy with a lower ceiling. Physically alone he looks like he could never hit over 20 HR so they question the choice to make the absolute decision that THIS is the guy of the future. How can we say there isn't another 2B out there (via FA, Draft, trade, etc.,) who can't do better.
I am pretty attached to Pedroia because I love the type of player he is. He's not the only one like that, we've all played with someone like him in the past. He's scrappy, reliable, extremely talented and very smart. I think the Sox should set aside one or two positions on the team where they take a high OBP guy with plus defensive and clubhouse abilities. Those two players, in my mind, are Youkilis and Pedroia. I think they can both be around affordably for the next 5 years or so and each can still get on base at a .370+ clip.