A comment I made in the gamethread, based on a comment by someone else, got me thinking about this hypothetical scenario and where everyone would stand.
The situation: It is Game 7 of the World Series. Both you and your opponent are building a new team from scratch, but the only players available to you are current and former Red Sox players, all of them in their primes.
The question: You pick first. Who do you take to build that team around.
Personally, I think for most people this would come down to two choices. Either Ted Williams, arguably (a weak argument against, probably) the greatest hitter in the history of baseball, or Pedro Martinez, arguably the best pitcher the Sox have ever had.
My answer? Pedro. I can't find these exact stats, but I am willing to bet that the percentage of games Pedro struggled, compared to the number of games he pitched, is a lot lower than the percentage of at-bats that Ted Williams did not reach base. Granted, the number of ABs for Ted and the number of GS for Pedro are drastically different, but my point is that it seems much more likely that in a one-game playoff, Pedro could shut down an opposing team far more easily than Ted Williams could carry his team offensively if his pitcher struggled.
Pedro was dominant at his prime, maybe more dominant than any pitcher any of us have seen in our lifetimes. If I had one chance to win it all, I'd start Pedro, and sacrifice any other pitcher or position player to do it.
Who would everyone else pick? Williams? Pedro? Or someone else? Juilo Lugo, perhaps?