I agree with most of your post, Jacko. Except the "on the block" part. I don't think Montero is "on the block," or being actively shopped. I think all along the Yanks have shown a reluctance to deal him as he has that once in a generation type potential, but they were open to the idea in this instance because of all the factors that you mentioned with the catching depth (and the fact that they are all better defensively), on top of the fact that an ace pitcher would be coming back the other way. When someone is on the trading block, it usually indicated that the team is actively looking to move that player, which I don't think is the case here. I wouldn't expect the Yanks to trade Montero for an Oswalt, Dunn, Lilly, Berkman, etc. So if the one thing you've drawn from this "experience" is that Montero is on the block, I would take another look at the situation if I were you. I think the Yanks would be dumb to explore another trade for him without getting a top 2% player at a given position in return. I actually like the way it worked out, being that we get to keep Montero and possibly/likely sign Lee in the offseason. But like I said, I don't think Montero is "on the block," and I hope to see him hitting bombs in the Bronx for years to come.