Because thats all they have on us, the fact that we had a $200 mil payroll and didnt make it to the series...btu then again, neither did they. They act like theyre some small market team competing with 200mil. They seem to forget they have the second largest payroll.
Last notable was the signings of Tony Womack and Jaret Wright (that wasnt Cashman's idea, the scouts said that he was very impressive and that we should sign him, so George jumped on board)...but I get your point
I cant stand fans like you. You just revealed your own ignorance. Brian Cashman has made deals before the 2004 season just to let you know. You guys seem to only pay attention to what has happened 2003 and beyond (seems to be when the Sox really hit the national spotlight...frontrunners are we?). Cashman has been the GM since 1998, and been in the organization for many years before that. I said he has made deals throughout the years that make you say WOW, not deals in the last 2 years that make you say WOW.
Example A) David Justice--That was a magnificent trade made, and without the addition of Justice, we dont win the 2000 World Series, let alone the pennant.
Example B ) Roger Clemens--aquiring Clemens in 1999 would be like aquiring Pujols today. Yes, I know im comparing a pitcher and a hitter, but its the best comparrison because of the stature of the player. Clemens was coming off 2 Cy Youngs in a row and was considered the best pitcher in the game at that point.
Example C) A-Rod--yes, I know you guys are gonna jump on me about the money thing, but seriously...if you look at the details of this trade, all of the money that he had deffered and all of the money he had the Rangers pick up, and how fast he had that deal worked out, it was a magnificent job by Brian Cashman, and nobody can deny that (though im sure all of you guys will try).
Example D) Chuck Knoblauch--no, his career didnt turn out the way we would have hoped, but in case you guys who know nothing about baseball pre-2003 (*cough* riverside *cough*) didnt know, because you only care about the game when your team is a national commodity, Chuck Knoblauch was the best leadoff hitter in the game at that point, possibly the best second basemen, and was on the fast track to Cooperstown. Obviously it didnt all work out, but it was a great trade as Knobby wasmkey for us for so many years.
Those are just a few...I could name several others.
with all due respect, I think we have a right to come and defend our GM when he is being bashed by you guys...regardless of if this thread has a damn thing to do with the Yankees or not.
exactly...nobody can take away the fact that Theo is a great gm, especially considering hwo young he is and his limited experience. In my point, I was just stating that he should get a few more years under his belt before he feels he deserves to be the highest paid GM.
For instance, if you're on a job for say 8 years or something, and some new guy walks in, gets all the fringe benefits, gets all the salary raises, etc.. just after 2 years, you're going to be pissed because he pretty much just broke into the business. Let Theo get his feet a little but more wet before we anoint him Branch Rickey.
excellent point...and notice how none of them argued with it after you said that.