Here is what I would have done. There are games when Farnsworth really has it, and then there are games when he doesn't have it at all. He walked Castillo on four pitches (you know something is wrong when you walk Castillo considering all he can do is hit singles). I agree with letting him face Punto, considering Punto isn't too great a hitter and no one would be warmed at that point. But you have to recognized when Farnsworth doesn't have it and that should be apparent after what he did with the first batter. So now there is a runner on second and one out. Mike Myers is on this team for a reason, because he is supposed to be able to get out lefties just about every time. If he can't do this he is taking up a roster spot. I bring in Myers to face Mauer, if he gets him out, I walk Cuddyer intentionally. Then I let Myers face Morneau. Obviously this is a difficult task for Myers, asking him to get out two of the best left handed hitters in the game back to back. But the way I see, if he is not getting out lefties nearly every time, he is taking someones spot on the roster who could give the Yankees more innings. I also say this because Joe has to recognize when Farnsworth doesn't have it and that should have been apparent right away.