Also, for the most part, Girardi managed this game well. You cannot manage this game to go 15 innings. You have to give your team the best chance to win at the current time, while maybe thinking a couple innings ahead. The way I saw it, Girardi made one mistake. There was no reason to take Joba out after only a third of an inning. He should have pitched into the 8th instead of Hughes, and they could have saved Hughes for after Rivera.
Otherwise, the way he managed was excellent. He use of Rivera this postseason has been fantastic. Girardi has taken full advantage of one of his best weapons this postseason.
He used Coke appropriately, turning around Figgins to his much weaker side and going lefty vs. lefty against Abreu. After that he needed to bring in Joba to face the RHHs in the middle of the order.
He brought Aceves out at the appropriate time, because he was shaky in the 11th inning when he gave up the run and he got extremely lucky going Vlad. You cannot let him face Morales batting left handed in that situation. Considering the way Morales hits right handed, along with how Aceves was throwing the ball, you have to protect against the home run in that situation.
After that Marte was useful simply to turn Morales around, but you cannot keep leaving him in to face RHHs.
Then he went to Robertson.
Girardi cannot manage for this game to go 14 or 15 innings. You cannot expect a manager in the postseason to do that. However, even if it did, it would have been the Yankees' fifth starter against the Angels' fifth starter. For the 14th inning, those are not awful odds. I've been one of Girardi's biggest critics this year, but he has done an excellent job in the postseason.