No, I understand you're reasoning behind bashing Theo. That wasn't my point. I was focusing on the A+ you gave Cashman and wondering how the hell you can give him that grade. I don't care what Igawa's salary is in line with, posting that much for a back of the end rotation guy isn't worth it by the logic you're using. I would be happier if your grade was more in the mid-low B range. It could spike quickly, but he's essentially made 2 moves this season that will have immediate impact - Pettite (good signing), and Igawa (not so good for what was spent on him). Thus, an above average grade, but not a perfect grade, seems acceptable.