You can't possibly watch every inning, every play, of Coco Crisp's performance. We use stats to help us out. They are a measure of performance.
This is so f***ing stupid.
If Coco Crisp is such an amazing fielder, why does every fielding metric have him as below average in CF? He's a great LF, but he's not a good CF. It's really that simple. I mean, even watching the guy play, he makes bad reads, doesn't have ANY arm, and throws with little accuracy. Even your dumbass can admit that.
David Eckstein makes great plays, and I'm pretty sure Wes Helms has too, but you don't rate a player on making great plays.
You don't want us to use stats, yet you use one right here?
It also happens to be the worst stat to use for a fielder.