Or the guy who thinks Bronson Arroyo is worth 10 wins above average, or Dice-K would have an ERA north of five if he pitched in Cincy.
Oh, how about the guy who thinks Saito's ERA will be worse than Chris Ray's if he moves to the AL?
The guy who thinks that the AL has more HR's then the NL?
Oh, you think guys are clutch when they hit .228 in clutch situations.
Dude, if you did any research, you'd see that Pena is a remarkably better player when he starts. Look at players similar to Pena. How do they hit in pinch hitting/start once in awhile situations?
Show me where I endorsed the J.D. Drew signing. I don't like giving left handed hitters long term contracts, in a ballpark that suffocates power. The only thing I'm guilty of is, believing Drew will hit closer to .280, then to .220.
I don't know. Is he playing everyday in order to make that judgment?
Do you? You thought Scott Spiezio was on the Yankees, and was an integral part of their championship run.
The Reds are 4th in RS.
Very poor.
This is stupid. You bring up success of three relief pitchers, and two pitchers who made the switch into their 40's. Do you ever look at anything in a macro sense? As of right now, the average ERA's in 2007 are:
AL - 4.43
NL - 4.30
A difference of 0.13. Not even close to the difference you pronounce.
It gets even smaller.
2006:
AL - 4.56
NL - 4.49
2005:
AL - 4.35
NL - 4.22
I'm still waiting for you to give me anything useful.
Again, this is very stupid. You cherry pick the stats of a few pitchers and claim that there is a massive gap in the runs being scored. There isn't. Get over it.
A guy with chronic elbow problems, gets surgery, responds well to it, and performs at his talent level. Did you watch Carpenter pitch in 2004? He would have dominated both leagues.
Oh, I get it. he dont lok liek a big lguer he must b one of dem stat guis de be talkin bout.
Despite having nearly .50 points of WHIP on Broxton, Saito is not a legit closer. I guess it's because he's Asian.
I'll ignore the fact that it's stupid to base your findings on 7 games, but:
World Series RS/RA - (last 7 WS)
NL - 162/150
AL - 150/162
In the big boy show, doesn't look like these NL pitchers are imploding at the rate you say.
Of course, you ignore the part about the debate being who is better RIGHT NOW.
I'll give Saito an additonal 0.13 ERA points for pitching in the NL.
ERA - 1.72
ERA - 1.82
Still, Saito.
Both pitchers have been dominant, but Saito's got an edge.
lol wut