Well, Shoppach went 1-4 with a K today. He hit .278/.316/.556/.872 in 5 September games.
FINAL SEASON LINE:.233/.321/.463/.784; .34 (46/137) BB/K ratio; 25 2B, 22 HR in 113 G and 399 AB's and 454 PA
Rate Stats: AB/HR- 18.1; AB/K- 2.9; PA/BB- 9.9; AB/2B- 16; AB/XBH- 8.5
Here's my final analysis:
Shoppach has officially claimed the title of the best power hitting catcher in PawSox history, all while doing it in his first season there, making it that much more impressive. As a 24 year-old, Shoppach outproduced 25 year-old Jason Varitek, while Varitek played in the hitter friendly PCL and Shoppach played in the neutral IL.
Shoppach has fantastic power, utilizing all fields, and destroys left-handed pitching. He also takes a good share of walks (nearly 50 for a 24 year-old in his first year at AAA is very good) and had an OBP nearly 100 points above his BA most of the season. His defense is also second to none. He has amazing footwork behind the plate and an outstanding release. He threw out over 35% of prospective base-stealers against him, all while catching many games from Frank "The Snail" Castillo.
Shoppach still has a great deal of improvements to make, though. He strikes out far too much against right-handed pitching. Many of those are on curveballs that he cannot wait back on and he swings in front of them, while only a few are on fastballs by him or being caught looking.
Being off on timing one's swing on curveballs is a fixable problem. Our current catcher had the very same issue in his younger days, as did our right-fielder and many Hall of Famers, Mike Schmidt being the most renowned. At his age, he can certainly make the adjustment; he just needs a little more time. If thrown into the MLB fire, he would probably be a league average catcher and hit something like .220/.300/.425/.725 without really taking the Fenway effect into consideration, which could boost some of those numbers. A half-season, or potentially even full season, at Pawtucket would likely be better in preparing him for the big leagues.
Without straying too off-topic, I am still not in favor of giving Jason Varitek a long-term deal based solely on him as a player and catcher without taking in outside factors.