Red Sox Rule 5 Draft Primer: Recent History and 2025 Player Preview

[Nick John]

The Rule 5 Draft will take place later today, December 10, at the conclusion of the Winter Meetings. With it comes an opportunity for teams to poach talented minor league players from their competition. For the players selected, it allows them an opportunity that may not have been reachable with their former organization.

The Boston Red Sox have been on the receiving end of both outcomes, having lost players due to the draft while also significantly improving their roster because of it. Taking a look back at every Rule 5 Draft in the past 10 years, Boston has selected four players — two infielders and two pitchers. All four players were influential in their own ways in Boston, with infielder Jonathan Araúz arguably being the worst of them depending on who you ask.

The first of the four, Josh Rutledge, had been a part of the Red Sox organization prior to being selected. He was acquired in a July 2015 trade for Shane Victorino and appeared in 39 games before being outrighted off the roster. Rutledge would go on to sign a minor-league deal with the Colorado Rockies. only to then be selected by the Red Sox in the Rule 5 Draft. Overall, Rutledge would go on to play in 104 games across three seasons where he hit .252/.319/.313 with nine doubles, a triple, one home run and 22 RBIs. Defensively, Rutledge found playing time all around the diamond but was mainly used at third base and second base by the Red Sox. After the 2017 season, the team allowed him to become a free agent where he would go on to sign with the San Francisco Giants.

The other infielder was Jonathan Araúz, who, at the time, was the Houston Astros’ 25th-ranked prospect by MLB Pipeline. Just 20 years old, Araúz was coming off a season that saw him hit .249/.319/.388 with a .707 OPS between High-A and Double-A. The Red Sox liked what they saw and picked in the Rule 5 Draft. Fortunately for them, the Covid-shortened 2020 season made it easy to keep him on the active roster for the entire season.

Appearing in 25 games, Araúz wound up hitting .250/.325/.319 with a .644 OPS as a 21-year-old. He also had two doubles, one home run and nine RBIs. His time with Boston was not for long, spending most of the 2021 season in Triple-A where he provided depth for the major-league club. In 28 games with Boston in 2021, Araúz slashed just .185/.274/.369 with three doubles and three home runs to go along with eight RBIs. Though, Araúz did deliver what may have been one of the biggest hits in the second half of the 2021 season in a late-August game against the Cleveland Guardians. In need of the win, Araúz wound up hitting a three-run home run that gave the Red Sox the lead and eventually the game.

He would go on to play in just six games with Boston in 2022 before being released, bringing his time with Boston to 59 games across three seasons for a stat line of .204/.280/.320 with a .600 OPS along with five doubles, four home runs and 18 RBIs. Defensively, he mainly played second base or shortstop but did have a few appearances at third base.

However, it was the 2020 offseason that saw the Red Sox have their best Rule 5 selection of the bunch, as the team selected a starting pitcher from the Yankees who had injury issues. That pitcher was Garrett Whitlock, whom the team transformed into a key reliever in his rookie season. That year, Whitlock was a big part of why the Red Sox made it back to the postseason, anchoring the backend of the bullpen and being an arm that could get the ball to closer Matt Barnes. Overall, he went 8-4 with 14 holds and two saves in 46 appearances. He threw 73 1/3 innings out of the pen and struck out 81 batters. And after a few injury-filled years after trying to convert back to starting, Whitlock was back to his old self in 2025 as he appeared in 62 games, tossing 72 innings and striking out 91 batters. Whitlock in his five seasons with Boston has gone 25-14 with a 3.13 ERA in 165 appearances, 23 of them starts. He’s tossed 313 2/3 innings and struck out 343 batters. He’ll be looked to as a key figure in the bullpen for the 2026 season.

The other prominent reliever that the Red Sox got through the draft was Justin Slaten, a key piece of the bullpen since his rookie season in 2024 where he appeared in 44 games and went 6-2 with a 2.93 ERA. He would throw 55 1/3 innings and strike out 58 batters proving himself to be a reliable option for manager Alex Cora. His sophomore season may not have looked as good on paper, but Slaten’s numbers were hampered by a couple bad outings in April along with some missed time due to injury. In 2025, he only appeared in 36 games because of that, tossing 34 innings and striking out just 25 batters while having an ERA of 4.24. Now healthy, Slaten will look to repeat his 2024 season and continue to build off of his first two years in Boston.

Taking that into consideration, should the Red Sox draft someone on Wednesday (which isn’t a guarantee at the moment), the team could likely turn towards someone they deem as a potential impact arm or even a multi-position player. As an organization, the team has developed an affinity for versatility up and down the roster.

With the way the roster is currently constructed, the Red Sox have limited options for their corner infield positions and could look for a potential diamond in the rough to fill out the back of their bench, especially if the player has showcased some in-game power. Of the players who could likely come off the bench, Nick Sogard, David Hamilton and Nate Eaton are not known for their power, and it’s very likely that Romy González could be in the starting lineup based on how the rest of the offseason plays out.

With that said, the Red Sox could look to a young, versatile player to help fill out the end of their bench. Now, a potential option should he fall to the Red Sox could be their very own former prospect, Blaze Jordan. Traded to the Cardinals, Jordan struggled with Memphis after a very impressive season in the Boston organization. After hitting .198/.242/.366 with the Redbirds, the Cardinals did not add him to their 40-man roster to protect him. Jordan has potential game-altering power as he’s hit double-digit home runs in every season he’s been healthy. He has a keen eye and understands the strike zone as he only struck out in 60 at-bats last season.

Should the Red Sox choose to target an arm, they could choose to go after Chicago White Sox prospect Peyton Pallette. Pallette fits the mold of both Whitlock and Slaten, being a pitcher who has a strong fastball, as it sat 94-96 mph last season. It was part of a repertoire that includes a high-spin curveball that was consistently north of 3000 rpms with break that sees it fall right off the table. He also threw a changeup that had a 50.8% whiff rate during his time in Triple-A in 2025. To compare his curve to Slaten’s, Pallette gets almost 300 more rpm than Slaten does on his. Thanks to those three pitches, Pallette posted a career-high 12.0 strikeouts per nine innings last season between Double-A and Triple-A.

The Red Sox do have an open spot on their 40-man roster after trading Vaughn Grissom to the Los Angeles Angels, so they can make one pick in the Rule 5 Draft as things currently stand. However, since the draft order goes from the worst record to the best, there is a chance the Red Sox might have to trade for the player much like they did with Slaten (who was actually selected by the Mets as part of a trade with the Red Sox for 2023 10th-round draft pick Ryan Ammons and cash considerations).

The Red Sox have a lot of planning to do as the Winter Meetings come to a close, and that begins with how they choose to approach the Rule 5 Draft.

View full article

[TheoBallgame9]

WTF is wrong with you people? Why, for the love of God do you not id a photo????