Random Trade Idea

[CrespoBlows]

Which group of players would you rather have?

[ORS]

The one on the left.

[CrespoBlows]

Heh. I forgot I even created this. I was going to do a poll. It would have been:

 

Schilling, Lester, Youkilis, and Loretta

 

Or

 

Sheets, Capuano, Fielder, and Weeks.

[AlexanderTheGreat13]

Well at this stage in their careers and going foward I would easily take the Brew Crew.

[ORS]

Easily the 4 from Milwaukee.

[DUSTINMOHR4LIFE]

the crew... weeks is going to be one of the best 2B

[schillingouttheks]

The Crew.

[noonanberg]

Sox foursome. Sheets is always hurt. Weeks will be good, but he's not going to be great. Youkilis is a great guy to have. Schilling while done in a year and a half may still play more games in that span than Sheets will in 4. Lester will be a great #3 for years to come. Loretta is good. Plus, he's hopefully only here until Pedroia comes up.

[elsrbueno]

The Brewers' foursome.

 

Lester is a #3 maybe a #2 eventually, but Capuano is that RIGHT NOW and not old. Sheets is younger and when healthy better than Schilling-- right now. Fielder is a nice power hitter and probably will have a short career like his old man but Youkilis is already 27, so he's not exactly young. He's an on base machine but doesn't have the offensive prowess of Fielder.

 

Weeks is probably going to be an outfielder in a few years if he can't improve his defense. This diminishes his offensive value but he's still a significant threat. Loretta's a 1 year rental.