Hard for anyone to argue that recent top-rated prospects like The Big Three of the Boston farm system have been overrated -- so far... but overrated by whom?
Posters on fan forums? The Fenway PR department? Absolutely; we all live for next homegrown hero to lead us to the promised land. And Red Sox Nation has been blessed for decades with young players bursting from the minors into almost instant MLB All-Stars: Fisk, Lynn, Rice, Clemens, Boggs, Mo, Nomar, Bogey, Mookie and Raffy to name a few.
But it's not our fault professional evaluators and pundits named Kristian Campbell Minor League Player of the Year, or Roman Anthony the #1 Prospect in baseball, or rated Marcelo Mayer with the best defense and hit tool in the draft.
Maybe the hype got to them all too fast and they've struggled with adjustments. Guys that good have little experience ever failing at baseball in their entire young lives. The Sox are just unlucky right now, but there's plenty of time for good careers (as long as a people person and not a robot doesn't bat them leadoff and clean-up right away).