The Yankees had a terrible off-season--they made one mistake after another. They should have signed Corbin, kept Sheffield, and avoided James Paxton. In addition, I don't know how they pass on a future HOF in Machado. They should have signed Machado, a two way player, and traded the hyped M.Andujar while his trade value was high and inflated.
Cashman went through a stretch where he made some excellent moves, acquiring DiDi, A.Hicks, Torres. But more recently Cashman has been trending in the other direction and it all started going wrong for him when he traded for numb nuts Geancarlo Stanton.