notin
-
Posts
53,401 -
Joined
-
Last visited
-
Days Won
45
Content Type
Profiles
Boston Red Sox Videos
2026 Boston Red Sox Top Prospects Ranking
Boston Red Sox Free Agent & Trade Rumors, Notes, & Tidbits
Guides & Resources
2025 Boston Red Sox Draft Pick Tracker
News
2026 Boston Red Sox Draft Pick Tracker
Forums
Blogs
Events
Store
Downloads
Gallery
Everything posted by notin
-
Some teams just deal them to complete trades. Like how the Sox got Pivetta, Fitts, Winckowski, Sandlin and Judice…
-
46 years. That 1978 rotation with Eck, Tiant, Lee and Torrez was king. Not that s***** 1974 rotation with Tiant, Lee, Reggie DH
-
Yes. My influence with Breslow is strong…
-
First of all, it was seven off the top of my head. Was I supposed to name every young pitcher who was traded to disprove that no young pitchers get traded? Second, there are two philosophies with young pitchers. Some teams E absolutely do like to keep them. But others don’t mind dealing them because they pan out at a much lower rate than position players. I only named pitchers who have panned out; the list of high profile pitching prospects that didn’t and got traded is much, much larger…
-
Devers signs 11 year $331 million extension
notin replied to Jasonbay44's topic in Boston Red Sox Talk
There's also some fun reports that they treat their minor leaguers worse than every other organization... -
Questioning everyhting I say? https://www.boston.com/sports/boston-red-sox/2023/09/15/red-sox-turn-down-chris-sale-trade/ (Subscription required) https://www.sportskeeda.com/baseball/news-fact-check-did-chaim-bloom-refuse-trade-chris-sale-exploring-details-controversial-move-focused-on-injured-star And probably other better sources if you ever Google it...
-
Devers signs 11 year $331 million extension
notin replied to Jasonbay44's topic in Boston Red Sox Talk
Until this year, it is hard to argue Trout had a weak lineup around him. Ohtani did win two MVP awards to go with Trout's three (along with four other second place finishes). The Angels have struggled mightily to get a good pitching staff, largely due to a weak farm system and some very questionable free agent signings. It seems like the only free agent SPs they pay heavily for are ones coming off one good season after several seasons of mediocrity or worse. That's simply a bad strategy... -
No one was unhappy with Sale as much as they were frustrated with his frequent injuries and possibly unhappy with the length of his extension. And the general attitude of the guy does depend heavily on his current health. Many were upset with Bloom for not trading Sale and his entire contract for nothing. And now many are upset with Breslow for trading Sale and getting back a young MLB player...
-
Next year they also might start Story at SS and hold off on Mayer until Trevor gets injured...
-
You just said other teams don't trade them. I named several examples of pitchers they did trade. Naming one team that does not have one (unless you count Pivetta) doesn't disprove this. But if you like, the Sox did trade for Pedro and Sale, which have been two of the best TOR arms in the last 30 years, and the Sox traded for them both...
-
He might be right, but it’s just a baseball discussion. That’s what these forums are for…
-
And yet it seems to happen anyway. Zac Gallen being a prime example. Also Tyler Glasgow, Dylan Cease, Cole Ragans, Joe Ryan, AJ Puk, Sandy Alcantara, etc..
-
5/21 SOX @ Rays 6:50PM ET
notin replied to SPLENDIDSPLINTER's topic in Mike Grace Memorial Game Thread Forum
Two starting pitchers taking on their former teams… -
I just don't have faith in Sale staying healthy...
-
Fine, but a run like Sale had with injuries is far from typical. I mean, who breaks a rib throwing a pitch?
-
Also possible. I don't know if they possess the same "damn the luxury tax - full throttle" mentality you see in Los Angeles and New York. But I do think they were in a better position to take the risk on Sale's health due to their pitching-heavy minor league system. At worst, Sale buys some time for their prospects if he can't stay on the field...
-
You can. The primary reason I wouldn't is the Sox have better outfield depth than starting pitching depth...
-
Obviously this team would be better today with Sale instead of Grissom. But at the time this trade was made, everyone anticipated the Sox were a given to be in last place in the AL East and out of the postseason picture probably fairly early, and Sale's involvement was a huge question mark given the past 4 seasons. Could they have waited and dealt him at the deadline? Sure. But then you're gambling that he doesn't get hurt again, a gamble they have lost 4 seasons in a row...
-
The entire premise of this thread is that StephCurry does not have any faith in Duran maintaining this level of play. He may be right; he may be wrong. He's no saying his assessment is superior to the Sox scouts. Just that he is putting more faith in the pre-2024 version. And if anyone does think this is as good as it gets, it is certainly a valid viewpoint to think Duran is a logical trade candidate if the Sox are out of contention by the deadline...
-
If the Sox stay in the hunt, they cetainly cannot trade Duran. He is a big part of their limited offense. If they are 10 games out of the third wild card in July, then what? Obviously they will try to move as many potential free agents as they can - Jansen, O'Neill, Martin, Pivetta. They probably won't be able to move them all, but they will probably try. But if some team does make an intriguing offer for Duran, do you hold? We've seen controllable outfielders get some fairly impressive returns. i remember when Adam Eaton was traded on his team-friendly contract to the Nationals for Lucas Giolito, Reynaldo Lopez and Dane Dunning. That's a franchise-altering return. If the Sox can get such a return, should they do it? The other option is to keep Duran for his last 3 seasons, which doesn't look like such a bad option either...
-
I bet the Braves are pleasantly surprised. If they expected him to start out this good, they probably don't ask the Sox to include so much cash...
-
There were plenty of experienced arms who signed MiLB deals. The Sox signed none of them. Even if that starter comes through with a 5.00 ERA, it is still better than burning out the bullpen every 5 games. That will come back to haunt the sox later if they have to keep doing it...
-
Even if it is not an ace per se, if the Sox can get a controllable SP, is he worth a deal? With BTV going to a pay model, I don't know the values right now. But if you can get a 2-3 starter with 3 years of control, do you pull the trigger? Some suggestions - Mackenzie Gore? Alek Manoah? Nick Lodolo? Josiah Gray? Reid Detmers? These are all pitchers who reach free agency one year prior to Duran, and are all varying degrees of good but none would be considered ace level today. Not sure what teams would actually want Jarren, however. But I am not asking if those teams would pull the trigger...
-
If the Sox can stay within striking distance and actually decide to be buyers, Lugo is the prime sell high candidate right now...
-
It's not working out, but given what Sale has and has not done in the past 4 years, I totally understand why this deal was made. But I can't rank this trade anywhere near the Betts trade, and not even with the Bagwell trade. And I think if the Sox had any inclination Sale would actually be healthy, they either don't make this deal or trade Sale for a lot more and pay a lot less, if they pay anything at all...
