notin

I would have liked Manaea, but I wanted no part of Luzardo. Coming off back surgery, no one knows how he’ll hold up…

And they’re both fringey RHP, except for Arenado..

We got Arenado?

Then you’re going to be very disappointed when you learn the Sox haven’t signed a single one of the 2025-26 MLBTR top 50….

So.. the Giants…

“Safer” is a relative term. Just because something is safer than something else didn’t mean it is safe. If you want to know why Sandoval is safer than Buehler or Means, his injury history is much less than either…

For a 34yo? It’s fair value. Not like Walker is 31…

I do think it’s getting a bit overboard with building next season’s staff. It’s not a bad thing, but it’s frustrating sometimes. But the Sox did add Crochet, which feels like it’s getting overlooked. And the rotation even as it stands now is actually pretty good…

Hey they were better than Eric Hosmer and Luis Urias…

It’s also only December 21st, and it’s certainly not uncommon for moves to come later. As of now, only 17 of the MLBTR Top 50 have signed, including only 4 of the top 11. It’s not like everyone else in MLB is out there lapping us. Also it’s very important to use only broad categories so as to make sure people don’t go thinking there is a difference between Garrett Crochet and Justin Wilson. Don’t let them fool you!!

The Sox will have 10 starting pitchers on the 40 man roster once they add Sandoval. (Booser was traded yesterday to create room.). They have already taken steps to replace Crawford…

Buehler is another Rehab Project, and I think people cling to him because they like the high ceiling. But this is a pitcher whose career includes parts of 7 seasons spanning 8 years with 12.2 career bWAR, 7.1 of which came in one year back in 2021. I don’t think that’s his ceiling anymore. He might be safer than Means. In the long run, Sandoval is definitely the smarter, safer choice.

What’s the difference between Buehler and Means? They’re one year apart in age, and both injured all the time. Buehler is slightly healthier (which isn’t saying much), but Means is a better pitcher…

I don’t think titles justify every move. Trading Bagwell for Andersen was never going to be a good move, regardless of the final outcome that season…

It would hardly be surprising if his rapid drop in performance followed by TJ surgery were both connected events. There are precedents, including current Sox minor leaguer Michael Fulmer, who just fell apart for no apparent reason while pitching out of the Cubs’ bullpen, and then had his second TJ. (Not sure why, after two TJs, Breslow is contemplating a return to the rotation for Fulmer.)

It’s arguable they overpaid for Story, but there are two clear sides. What’s inarguable is that they “jumped” on him and didn’t do their due diligence. A couple days ago on this forum I said a lot of people view signings they don’t like as the result of laziness or sloppiness by the front office, strongly implying if these people put in the work, things would work out better. Now I do not know everything that does into signing an MLB free agent, but I am far more than 100% confident in believing that process is more thorough and involved than most realize (myself includes).. We are talking in many cases about nine figure transactions, but want to believe they’re being done apathetically, quite often to justify a choice in player that we didn’t agree with…

So dont trade Casas. Because you can absolutely NOT get a young top of the rotation starter for him…

So the Sox unloaded Cam Booser to the White Sox for some 18yo Venezuelañ kid named Yhoiker Fajardo. I assume this was done to open up a roster spot for Sandoval and not some other forthcoming move…

Apparently the plan is to play Cody Bellinger in CF. Somewhere in the country right now, a very disappointed Trent Grisham is screaming “WHAT THE f***!!”

At one point, Rickey was the all time career leader in three categories - stolen bases, runs and walks, until Barry Bonds surpassed him in walks. It’s a small list for players who sat atop of three categories. And he is still the all time leader in the other two. One of the greatest offensive players ever…

$30+ mill for 7-8 years for a pitcher who can’t pitch, plus it can cost you rising star players that departure in free agency because you can’t afford the extensions. Plus not being able to afford a good replacement .It can hold a team back. If folks Yoshida’s remaining $55.8mill over 3 years are detrimental, what’s the overall effect of paying one ineffective player $250mill over 8 years? Think of a Giolito contract, but four times longer at 1.5 times the rate. If you think of Giolito as $38mill for one year as bad, what did you think of $116 mill for Sale for less than a year? And how did the Sox recoup those IP they didn’t get from Sale? Or Price? Again, if that player - let’s call him “Corbin” works out - the team does well and Corbin makes his case for Cooperstown. But if he flops right away, then what? Hope?

Long term deals in Free agency only work if you’re signing future Hall of Famers (or players close to that level). Freeman, Betts, Scherzer, Ohtani and maybe even Seager are all good candidates. Otherwise you’re just signing an aging player to wind down his days. Is Burnes a future Hall of Famer, or at least close? He’s 30 and in 4 yrs as a starter has been worth 16.5 bWAR. He might be able to post another 30ish bWAR in the next 7 years, but it wouldn’t be a shock if he didn’t. Plenty of teams have gone as big as LA with free agency and been complete flops, too. In fact, it’s probably the more likely outcome. Also Yamamoto is a different case, as he wasn’t as old as most free agents. Thats a big factor. So Will Burnes be another Scherzer? Or another Price? It costs about a quarter of a billion non-refundable US dollars to find out. If he is, then whoever signs him reaps huge benefits. But if he isn’t, that type of deal can keep a team non-competitive for nearly a decade. And maybe longer…

Then fix the pen and defense. Better defense will improve both the SP and the bullpen. If the Sox actually sign Alex Bregman, that helps the defense immensely. Or they could get a good defensive 3b back for Crawford, which is another option. (They missed out on Isaac Paredes, who would have been so perfect for Fenway.)

Like I’ve been telling you since the last Internet forum, free agency is about PR. By showing “interest”, the Sox are telling fans they’re willing to spend money without actually spending money. And in many cases, that’s probably the right decision. Burnes and Fried are certainly upgrades, but over the next few years are they better investments than Tanner Houck? Last year, Fried was worth 3.5 bWAR, Burnes was worth 3.4 bWAR, and Houck was worth 3.5 bWAR. Over the next 7 years, who will have the most bWAR? Max Fried? Corbin Burnes? Or Brayan Bello?

The Sox can get an innings water through free agency easier than they can a catcher. Of course if Crawford has all this value as an innings eater(which I agree with 100%), who should the Sox be bumping from the rotation for this new SP that many say we desperately need? Innings eaters are less effective in part time/reserve roles…