No, it is relevant, as some claim his "sowing signs" in 2023 meant something, yet the "signs" in 2021 were false hope signs.
Somehow, we were supposed to know the 2023 ones were for real.
Look, I get the idea that trading away any pitching, last winter was asking for this. Not replacing Sale, or Gio, once we knew he was hurt was a major mistake. I'm not sure anyone felt good about the totality of the pitching additions vs subtractions, last winter.
My point was only about Sale showing signs, several times after 2018, and never once did the hopes come anywhere near what he gave ATL in 2024. We guessed wrong. We stuck with him for a very long time, and just about every poster got sick of waiting and waiting.
We also got sick of Bloom signing other pitchers with injury histories and waiting for them to come off the IL, year after year. Brez tried to end that, and he failed, miserably. He traded our most injury prone pitcher and signed one that was known mostly for his durability- not his skill level. It back-fired, badly.
I wish we still had Sale. I wish Gio never got hurt. Neither happened, and we are struggling mightily because of that.
Had we traded him after 2021, and he went on to have a year like this in 2023, we'd have heard the same beefs.