How often do we get into the same boat at the deadline? We always need a SP'er, and the cost is always way too high to make it worthwhile- ALWAYS.
I do give Breslow credit for at least trying to be proactive in building up some very convincing rotation depth in his 2 short years with the team. Even I thought we had enough, although I did point out it was heavy on mediocrity & promise more than quality and dependability.
Look at the list we had, at the start of 2025:
Crochet: awesome trade & extension
Houck: sucked then IL
Buehler: highest AAV paid to a Sox pitcher since Price. Sucked.
Crawford: On IL, all year and just had a "setback."
Sandoval: Signed for August and 2026. A rare deal over 1 year.
Bello: One of the few brighter spots of this rotation.
Giolito: Largest contract given to any Sox pitchers since Nate, until Crochet's extension kicks in.
Fitts: Has shown some good, some bad and some meh.
Priester: Traded for Y Rod & Holebetz. (Added Harrison, recently)
Newcomb: A stab in the dark that ended up pretty bloody.
Dobbins: was pretty far down on the depth chart, and now is on the IL, after doing well.
Criswell: yet to be used a starter, despite decent success as one in '24.
Whitlock (FT pen arm, now) & Wink (60 Day IL): rightfully delegated to the pen. Murphy (60 Day IL) may end up in the pen, too.
Non 40 man roster depth: Uberstine, Drohan (IL,) Stock, Early (AA) and Sandlin (AA.)
That's a list at least 10 deep. We've tried 8, so far (No Sandoval, Fitts, Crawford and of course Priester.)