We won't know if it is overhype until he has a longer look. He was ranked pretty highly by people who know more about these things than we do.
He was younger than Moreland at every level, so the comp is a hard one to grasp.
I realize Moreland might do better both this year and going forward, but if Moreland struggles, Swi could get a chance to show he can do better. He could then go on and do better.
I do think Swihart might already be better than Moreland vs LHPs, so if Young gets hurt or an OF'er gets hurt and forces Young to play OF and not platoon at DH with HanRam, I think Swihart would be a better choice than Moreland, if only vs LHPs.
If Moreland struggles vs RHPs, maybe Swihart could do better. Sam Travis and Brock Holt would be the only in system competition for Swihart at 1B. I'm not sure anyone in our system would be a better DH, if Young, HanRam or Moreland gets hurt, regardless of Zips and Steamer having Holt or Travis projected with a higher OPS.
I know, Swihart could struggle in AAA and not be "the next guy in line", and maybe my hopes for Swihart are clouding my judgment, but it's not a stretch to think he could win the DH platoon job from Moreland or beat out Holt and Rutledge at 3B, if Pablo struggles of gets hurt this year.