Keeping Bogey. JD, Devers and Big Nate at market rates is not much different from signing free agents to replace them, in theory.
It's not much different from the Yanks keeping Judge. Was it prudent to extend LeMahieu? (It looks good now, but wait until 2025-2026.)
Look, I'm not saying I want all these guys gone. I'm driving the Devers Forevers bandwagon, and I wanted us to offer Betts 10-12 years. We may end up keeping Eovaldi. Who knows what the market is for JD.
I think we'll spend big, this coming winter, but I think we may be looking more at the window starting around 2024 or 2025 (Casas, Yorke, Mayer, Bello, Walter, Gonzalez and maybe others plus some key FAs.)