Indeed. I still think the moves he made before 2022 should have produced better results than the ones before 2021.
The moves before this year, when taken one by one, look even better, except for the lack of attention to the rotation and getting the one signing there horribly wrong.
The reliance on older vets, most with injury histories and younger unproven talent, as well as converted relievers to cobble together a rotation looked, on paper, like a bold gamble not likely to pay off, and yet for over a month now, we've used a revolving door of SP's due to injuries and the demotions of Kluver and Pivetta and seen quite stunning success.
The big question is, can they keep this up?
Earlier this year, I spoke to the need to start focusing on quality over quantity, but that maybe, just maybe, this group of SP'ers did have enough "quality" to make the quantity an asset. The jury is still out on that one, but somehow, the rotation has produced for over a month and is nearing the point where it has been good for longer than bad or mediocre.
If every SP'er was healthy, big if, I know, can we even be sure what the starting 5 would have been to start the season?
Sale
Paxton
Whitlock
Kluber
Pivetta
No Bello?
Houck, Crawford and Wink in the pen is pretty certain.
Cora did not really have to choose who to start, much, since Paxton, Whitlock and Bello started the season injured or recovering.
We started with...
Kluber, Sale, Houck, Crawford, Pivetta (2 rotations before Whitlock replace Crawford)
Kluber, Sale, Houck, Whitlock, Pivetta (one rotation before Bello was added
Kluber, Sale, Houck, Whitlock, Pivetta, Bello (two rotations with 6 men before Whitlock went on the IL)
Kluber, Sale, Houck, Pivetta, Bello (3 rotations before Paxton/Whitlock replaced the demoted Kluber/Pivetta)
Sale, Houck, Paxton, Whitlock Bello (one rotation before Sale went on IL)
Crawford, Houck, Paxton, Whitlock, Bello (Dermody got a start & Ort started a DH'er) This rotation has gone through 3 times.
Total GS: (Red: not intended to be in the starting rotation)
13 Houck
11 Bello
11 Sale
9 Kluber
8 Whitlock
8 Pivetta
7 Paxton
6 Crawford
1 Ort & Dermody
32 starts in RED with more to come.