Fascinating. I maybe have precipitated some of the above by attacking station 13 for his opinion about last Thursday's game decisions instead of doing what what illinoisredsox did, which was to explain what he thought Farrell had done right.
I continue to believe that most managers make reasonable game decisions because to me it's not rocket science. Some are more aggressive with their bullpens, but that is usually because they have good ones. For most of this season, we did not. In September we not only picked up a bunch of arms because of the roster expansion everyone had, but brought back some good arms like Uehara, Kelly, and Ziegler, who have clearly made a difference. Now, amazingly, the bullpen is borderline fantastic, regardless of who goes out there. In the Yankees series we had 2 (3?) starters falter, but who got pulled early, and the lineup made up the difference while the bullpen held the Yankees back. I don't think any of that makes Farrell a genius, but only shows how effective any manager can be when the bullpen is shutting the opposition down.
Girardi, I hasten to add, benefitted earlier this season from a fantastic bullpen. Now he has a lousy one and it shows.
Spudboy quoted Whitey Herzog who said that the difference between a good manager and a bad one was a great bullpen, and right now that's looking awfully true.