As for Elktonnick, his response to being presented with statistical evidence was to dismiss it because... well, because it works against him. He's ignoring evidence to cling to a gut feeling.
Yet you are basing your opinion that he can still hit on gut feelings as well. Right now, there is no statistical evidence that he is remotely like the Youk of a year ago. Also, you are saying, if I understand you, that he fell off a cliff last year because he was injured. That isn't exactly denying that he fell off a cliff, its giving what you feel is the reason he fell off a cliff. Maybe he just can't stay healthy playing 3B. All I know is that his numbers are hideous for almost a year and he has given me no objective reason to think that he is ever going to be productive again. This year he has 136 PAs and he is .231/.681. Its not like its 20ABs; its well over 100. Put that together with what he did last year and MY gut feeling is that he is not going to contribute in any significant way. At one point you have to give WMB a try. When is that, in your opinion?