I'm not convinced that that is Carp's true talent. They limited his exposure to LHP, which helped his numbers. I'm skeptical that he'd be that good as a full-time player. Also, keep in mind that he had a unsustainable .385 BABIP to go with that .880 OPS. A regression to the mean should be expected in 2014. He also doesn't add anything on the bases, or in the field.
I was also talking about him being a fit with the Giants. They already have Brandon Belt at 1B. They also just signed Mike Morse to play LF. I guess they could use him as a platoon partner for Morse, but that might be the worst defensive outfield duo in the history of the game.
I think Carp is a decent backup, but I don't think he'd be enough to pry Blanco away from the Giants, and I also don't think the Red Sox should consider him the heir apparent to 1B/DH.
That's not true. A .683 OPS is acceptable if the player adds value elsewhere. Blanco has a 2.3 and 2.8 WAR the last two seasons, because he is a good baserunner and a plus defender. He also gets on base at a pretty good clip. He'd be a steal for just Carp. Seeing that the Giants signed Morse to start over him, maybe they don't value him as much as they should. The Red Sox should take a look.