I've NEVER seen ANY team's offense do what the Yankees are doing this year. To have so many significant injuries, but then to have to so many former no-names step in and post crazy good numbers...it's been uncanny.
Aren't you the same guy who's been blaming everything on our starting pitching sucking?
You've even said it didn't matter if we had a better bullpen because the starting pitching would have sunk us anyway.
Did the 2004 Sox feel like a championship team when they were down 3-0 to the Yanks?
Did the 2007 Sox feel like a championship team when they were down 3-1 to the Tribe?
Not exactly...
But honestly, teams don't really feel like champions until they are champions.
Even late last season and into the playoffs, if you go through the threads here you'll find that a lot of people were very worried about our rotation coming through, because none of them had any postseason success. (Plus Sale's health was iffy.) A lot of people thought Houston would take us if we got that far.
Alex is a big believer in loading RH hitters against LH starters, and JBJ has bad splits, it's as simple as that.
But when your RH hitters are guys like Owings and Gorkys and they do squat, some questioning will occur.
Hard to say, but maybe 2-3 games better. Also, it's possible that if we were in a better position at the deadline they would have made a further effort to bolster the pen.
Well, he's certainly had enough time to think about it.
But there are external factors that could still have a big impact, like a bad report on Sale's elbow, or JD opting out.
Also, I should have mentioned, Rob Gronkowski retired at about the same age and for the same reasons as Luck, but his retirement seems to have met with a much better response, presumably because he did it early and because, well, because he's Gronk.