Have been watching Lavs numbers in Pawtucket all season for obvious reasons. If Olney is right it is encouraging as a sign of due diligence anyway. I think the logic "could" be that while Lavs "may" outhit Salty, and clearly has more upside defensively, he still has a ways to go to turn "upside defensively" into reality. The Sox are actually costing themselves runs when Salty is behind the plate and I am not sure Lavs solves that problem just yet. So I like the idea that they are looking outside first if that is what they are doing. They need to stop this defensive bleeding now. So much of what Salty does wrong does not show up on a stat sheet.
As for Webster, the only issue I have there is that I am not convinced that a kid like that saves you innings out of the pen. He may well be a better pitcher than Felix is at this point in terms of stuff especially. So the real balancing act is the chance the kid gets shelled a few times and loses confidence up here against better results in the games that he does pitch well. I don't think he saves innings for the pen.
Sunday provided a good example of the problem. Darvish made two mistakes during his stint and both were taken deep and accounted for the 3-0 advantage the Sox had early. Lester only made about two mistakes the whole game and both of those were taken out of the park.
Pitchers coming out of AA or AAA are simply not used to seeing almost every one of their mistake pitches going for hits if not extra bases and HR's. So then they have to adapt to the pressure of making no mistake pitches....almost an impossibility. But they end up going through all kinds of s*** about that one. I would chance it with Webster cause I am hoping the kid can handle what he is about to go through. I have no illusions abut Webster avoiding the usual issues for young starting pitchers.
As for the catching situation, I am glad they are looking if that is what they are doing and if they find a definitive way to stop the bleeding behind the plate I would prefer that to Lavs at this point. If they can't then bite the bullet, move on from the Salty experiment. Give Lavs the job, something the Sox rarely do with young talent.
As for the guys being replaced...sometimes you just have to give up. Felix is regressing! Salty is just not improving and they have given him tons of time.